The Counter

The Kitchen Edit

The Counter · Guide

The 3 best home ice cream makers, compared

Three very different machines, three very different relationships with dessert — here's how to pick the one that matches how you actually cook.

Home ice cream makers fall into three camps, and the camp you belong to has almost nothing to do with how much you want to spend. It has to do with how you cook. Are you the kind of person who decides at 9 p.m. that you want pistachio gelato? Or the kind who plans Sunday dessert on Friday morning? Or somewhere in between — happy to freeze a pint overnight if it means a smaller, cheaper machine on the counter? The three machines in this guide each answer that question differently. The Cuisinart ICE-30BC is the classic compressor-free bowl churner: cheapest to buy, but you have to pre-freeze the bowl for a full day. The Ninja CREAMi takes a different shortcut — you freeze the base itself in a pint container, then a powerful blade shaves and re-textures it into soft-serve in about two minutes. And the Instant Pot InstantChill is the no-planning option: a built-in compressor means you pour in a base and churn whenever you want, like a tiny version of what shops use. We ranked them by the kind of dessert-maker each one rewards. None of them is wrong, but two of them will frustrate you if you bought the wrong one. Below, our top pick for most people, the splurge for the impatient, and the budget classic for planners — plus, importantly, who each one is wrong for.

Our picks

  1. 01Best for most people:Ninja NC301 CREAMi Ice Cream Maker, for Gelato, Mix-ins, Milkshakes, Sorbet, Smoothie Bowls & More, 7 One-Touch Programs, with (2) Pint Containers & Lids, Compact Size, Perfect for Kids, Silver
  2. 02Best for impatient cooks:Instant Pot InstantChill Ice Cream Maker with Built‑In Compressor, No Pre‑Freezing, Real Ice Cream in Minutes\*, Gelato, Sorbet, Rolled, Non‑Dairy, Mix‑Ins, Easy Clean Up, Quiet, Makes Up to 2 Pints
  3. 03Best for planners on a budget:Cuisinart ICE-30BC Ice Cream Maker and Freezer Bowl Bundle
01

Best for most people

Ninja NC301 CREAMi Ice Cream Maker, for Gelato, Mix-ins, Milkshakes, Sorbet, Smoothie Bowls & More, 7 One-Touch Programs, with (2) Pint Containers & Lids, Compact Size, Perfect for Kids, Silver

From $199★ 4.6 · 15,269 ratings

The CREAMi wins on a combination of price, footprint, and sheer flexibility that the other two can't quite match. The trick is that it isn't really churning — it's re-texturing a frozen puck — which means you can freeze almost anything in the pint container (protein shake, leftover smoothie, a sweetened mix of Greek yogurt and frozen berries) and have it come out as something resembling soft-serve. Seven preset programs cover gelato, sorbet, smoothie bowls, and mix-ins, and the spin cycle takes about two minutes. The trade-off is the 24-hour freeze and the one-pint capacity, which is small if you're feeding more than two or three people. It's wrong for the person who wants to host a dinner party and serve everyone the same flavor, and it's wrong if your freezer is already packed and can't spare shelf space for upright pints. For everyone else — especially anyone interested in lower-sugar or high-protein bases — it's the most useful frozen-dessert machine you can put on a counter.

Check price on AmazonFull review →
Ninja NC301 CREAMi Ice Cream Maker, for Gelato, Mix-ins, Milkshakes, Sorbet, Smoothie Bowls & More, 7 One-Touch Programs, with (2) Pint Containers & Lids, Compact Size, Perfect for Kids, Silver
02

Best for impatient cooks

Instant Pot InstantChill Ice Cream Maker with Built‑In Compressor, No Pre‑Freezing, Real Ice Cream in Minutes\*, Gelato, Sorbet, Rolled, Non‑Dairy, Mix‑Ins, Easy Clean Up, Quiet, Makes Up to 2 Pints

From $250★ 5 · 23 ratings

If the idea of waiting 24 hours to make dessert sounds absurd to you, the InstantChill is the machine to buy. The built-in compressor is the same technology used in commercial countertop churners, scaled down: pour in a base, pick a preset, and you have real, scoopable ice cream — not re-textured frozen base — in about 20 minutes. It also handles gelato, sorbet, rolled-style, and non-dairy without you having to plan a day ahead. The catches are real, though. It's the most expensive option here, it takes up meaningful counter or cabinet space, and the two-pint capacity per batch isn't dramatically larger than the CREAMi's one-pint. It's wrong for the occasional dessert-maker who'd resent a big appliance sitting around between uses, and wrong for anyone whose kitchen is already at maximum gadget density. But for a household that makes ice cream on a whim — Tuesday night, no notice — nothing else here comes close.

Check price on AmazonFull review →
Instant Pot InstantChill Ice Cream Maker with Built‑In Compressor, No Pre‑Freezing, Real Ice Cream in Minutes\*, Gelato, Sorbet, Rolled, Non‑Dairy, Mix‑Ins, Easy Clean Up, Quiet, Makes Up to 2 Pints
03

Best for planners on a budget

Cuisinart ICE-30BC Ice Cream Maker and Freezer Bowl Bundle

From $155★ 4.7 · 96 ratings

The ICE-30BC is the machine that taught a generation of home cooks how to make ice cream, and it's still the right pick for one specific person: the planner who likes a project, has freezer space for a chunky bowl, and wants to make a proper two-quart batch — enough to actually serve guests dessert. The bundled second bowl is genuinely useful here, because once you start churning, you can swap in a frozen bowl and run a sorbet right after. Where it falls down is spontaneity. You have to remember to freeze the bowl 16 to 24 hours in advance, and if you forget, dessert isn't happening. It's wrong for small freezers, wrong for impulse cooks, and wrong for anyone who's tried this kind of churner before and bounced off it. But if you already think in terms of meal prep and you want the biggest batch for the lowest entry price, this is still the workhorse to beat.

Check price on AmazonFull review →
Cuisinart ICE-30BC Ice Cream Maker and Freezer Bowl Bundle

In closing

For most home cooks, the Ninja CREAMi is the right answer: it's compact, it's flexible enough to make everything from sorbet to a high-protein smoothie bowl, and the overnight freeze is a fair trade for how little space it takes. If waiting overnight is a non-starter and you genuinely make dessert on a whim, the InstantChill's built-in compressor earns its higher price and bigger footprint. The Cuisinart is still the value play, and the right call if you regularly need to feed a group of four or more from one batch — but only if you're the kind of cook who plans ahead. What would change our ranking? A bigger CREAMi-style machine with a two-quart container, or an InstantChill at a lower price, would scramble the order quickly.

Common questions

How did we rank these?
We weighted three things: how the machine fits real cooking habits (planned vs. spontaneous), total cost of ownership including freezer space, and texture quality for the price. We didn't rank purely on dessert quality, because all three make good ice cream when used as designed.
Is a compressor machine really worth the extra money?
Only if you'll use the spontaneity. A compressor lets you churn on demand without pre-freezing anything, which is genuinely useful if you make ice cream weekly or on impulse. If you make it a few times a year, a bowl-freeze or pint-freeze machine will serve you just as well for less money and less counter space.
Can any of these make dairy-free or low-sugar ice cream?
Yes — all three handle non-dairy bases (coconut, oat, almond) and lower-sugar recipes. The CREAMi has the edge for protein-forward or yogurt-based pints because its re-texturing approach is forgiving of unconventional bases, while traditional churners can struggle when there's less fat and sugar to stabilize the freeze.

Friday morning

Get the next edit in your inbox.

One curated kitchen pick a week. No noise. Unsubscribe whenever.